Written for Steering-committee sponsors, claims and underwriting leaders, and the people who have to select a first AI case at an insurer or an MGA.
What's in this playbook
This playbook is the operational document for a standing workshop method a steering committee at an insurer, or at an MGA, can work through when it has to select a first AI case. It is complementary to the Insurance AI Playbook already in this library, and is not a replacement for it. That playbook remains the industry map. This playbook will not reprint that map as the workshop method, will not invent a ranking by return, and will not give a different reading of the same firm. The Claims Intake (FNOL) Agent Playbook and the Claims Document-Processing Playbook remain companions for those later, bounded cases; this playbook will not reprint them. It will not write the separate MGA-submission, clearance, or pipelines-for-MGAs topics that sit later in the library plan.
What it is, instead, is a service playbook for selection itself: six families of workshop work, fourteen design tests, and a first-case path that, at the illustrative insurer, yields the same first case as in the Insurance AI Playbook. The workshop starts with an inventory of what is running and what is proposed, names consequence before a use is funded, and funds a bounded first case against a signed baseline — not an invented ranking, and not an unsupervised settlement or bind. The same method applies at an MGA, with an authorised person on every bind, quote and decline. This playbook will not invent a priority score, will not republish a workflow NPV as a forecast, and will not recommend, as a first case, a ranked program or an unsupervised settle or bind. A twelve-week framework is not a first case this playbook will recommend.
How the tests and the method are meant to be used
The financial method is The Complete Guide to AI Automation ROI. This playbook will not invent an insurer-or-MGA-selection-sector return, and it will not promise a twelve-week go-live. The 3.8x average first-year ROI across client engagements is an average, not a forecast or a commitment for any individual project. ROI is measured across client engagements against a baseline agreed before work starts. It is an average, not a forecast for any individual project, and is not used as a sector benchmark. Built to SOC 2 standards is the exact wording we use; it is not a certification of the reader's system.
The illustrative firm is the same hypothetical mid-size property and casualty insurer as in the Insurance AI Playbook, the Claims Intake (FNOL) Agent Playbook, the Enterprise AI Governance Framework, and the 2026 diagnostic: overall 15, Emerging, Governance the constraint at 1, with a next-step target of 24, Developing. Two claims pilots have been run; neither is in production with an operator. A third claims idea is being discussed as the "real" first case: an adjudication model that would settle low-complexity claims automatically. The honest first work, which this workshop method yields, is to write a proportionate governance path before a third claims pilot: put those two existing pilots on an inventory, with an owner, a sampling plan and a stop, and only then, if the tests pass, fund a bounded FNOL or document assist — extraction and completeness, a person on anything that opens, pays, or denies. An unsupervised settlement or deny is not a first case. The same method applies at an MGA; this playbook will not score a second firm. The firm is illustrative, not a sample. The target is a next level, not a timeline, and not a promise. A companion workbook, asymilink-insurer-mga-use-case-selection-playbook.xlsx, holds a family register, the fourteen tests, questions for counsel, a baseline sheet, and the same illustrative insurer. Do not wait to be Leading.
Six families of workshop work
each with an honest first case, a case that is too wide, and a gate. Each item below is the shape of the map; the full wording, honest first cases and “too wide” warnings are in the PDF.
F1
A workshop inventory of what is running and what is proposed (first)
F2
Consequence named before a use is funded
F3
A bounded first case, which at the illustrative insurer yields the same first case as in the Insurance AI Playbook
F4
A signed baseline on a named process, not an invented ranking
F5
The same method applied at an MGA, with an authorised person on bind, quote and decline
F6
Counsel and hosting, decided before a selected use is funded
The PDF gives, for each family, an honest first case, a case that is too wide, and a defined gate. The summaries above are the shape of the map, not a substitute for that wording.
Fourteen design tests (excerpt)
Fourteen design tests are applied to every case. The answers will differ. The standard does not. The full wording is in the PDF and the companion workbook.
T1–early
a named inventory; consequence named before funding; a signed baseline rather than a ranking this playbook will invent.
Mid-tests
a refusal to recommend an unsupervised settle or bind, or a ranked program, as a first case; counsel asked without a date taken from this document.
Later tests
the same method at an MGA, with an authorised person on bind, quote and decline; hosting decided before a selected use is funded.
A completed test sheet is not a certificate, not a compliance score, and not a finding that a system is safe or aligned with a named regime.
Get the guide and workbook
Enter your name, work email and company. The files appear on this page immediately. A backup download link is also emailed when email delivery is available.